Why I Wish You’d Ditch the Prong Collar (and What to Use Instead).
Recently, I’ve been coming home more often and ranting about yet another dog I’ve seen in a prong collar. After witnessing a Dachsund wearing one last week, I decided to put that energy somewhere more constructive than the ether. (M
y husband and friends are well-versed in my point of view by now).
So why does the presence of prong collars (also called pinch collars) bother me so much? Let me start by saying that I believe the dogs wearing them are being walked by a very well-meaning human/pet parent who thinks of their dog as a beloved member of their family (their baby, if you will) and whose deep love has probably spun their given name into any number of nicknames. I also believe that they genuinely don’t realize that the collar is causing their dog pain or, at the very least, discomfort. The dog has stopped pulling on the leash, and they’re so easy to manage when wearing this collar, so it must be a great option, right?
Are prong collars bad for dogs?
The result might look good from the human end of the leash, but it comes at a cost for the dog. Research on aversive training methods has found that dogs trained this way show more stress behaviors and higher levels of the stress hormone cortisol and may even become more pessimistic in outlook compared with dogs trained using rewards (Vieira de Castro et al., 2020). There's also no evidence that aversive methods work better than reward-based training (Ziv, 2017). That's why the American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior recommends using only reward-based methods for all dog training.
In addition, dogs learn by association. If your dog feels a pinch every time they lunge toward another dog, they may start to link that discomfort with other dogs, rather than with pulling. Over time, that can make a dog more worried or reactive on walks, not less.
And perhaps most importantly, a prong collar tells a dog what not to do, but it doesn't teach them what we'd like them to do instead.
How does a prong collar work?
A prong collar is made of metal or plastic links with prongs that tighten around a dog's neck when they pull on the leash. It works by causing discomfort when the dog pulls, which makes it an aversive tool: it stops a behavior by making it unpleasant.
E-collars work on the same principle, delivering a static shock (or sometimes a vibration) when the dog does something the human wants to stop. While this post focuses on prong collars, most of what is talked about here applies to both.
Why are prong collars so common?
For one, the dog training industry has different schools of thought. Balanced trainers, who use both rewards and corrections, often include aversive tools as part of their practice. Prong collars are also sold in pet stores as 'training collars’ - so it’s right there in the name. And these are two sources people who are looking to improve their dog’s behavior trust, so most people don’t think to ask, “Are prong collars bad for my dog?”.
What to use instead of a prong collar?

Dogs who haven’t learned how to walk on a leash yet are inclined to pull, rushing ahead or zigzagging in front of their human as they race to sniff that patch of grass or take in the information the last dog left on that tree, or say hi to the dog coming the other way. While everyone (human included!) is learning what nice leash manners look like through rewards-based training, a well-fitting harness is a great choice. Harnesses are non-aversive, gentle on your dog’s body and avoid pressure on the neck. With so many different options, here some tips for choosing a harness:
Choose a Y-shaped front. A Y-shaped harness sits on the breastbone and stays clear of the shoulder joints, so your dog can move naturally. Harnesses with a strap straight across the chest can slip down over the shoulders and get in the way of how your dog walks.
Look for a front clip. When your dog pulls, a front clip turns them gently back toward you, which makes loose leash training easier.
Try a double-ended leash. It's a great upgrade for stronger dogs. Clipping one end to the front ring and one to the back gives you gentle control without pulling your dog off balance.
Consider padding or a soft lining. A harness lined with fleece or neoprene spreads pressure over a wider area of your dog's chest, so it feels more comfortable if they do pull while they're learning. It also helps prevent rubbing and chafing, especially behind the front legs. This makes a real difference for short-coated or thin-skinned dogs like greyhounds, whippets and pit bull types, and for sensitive dogs who are more likely to notice an uncomfortable fit.
Whatever you choose, fit matters most: you should be able to fit two fingers under every strap, and nothing should rub behind the front legs.
Will a harness make my dog pull more?
No. Not knowing how to walk on a leash is what causes pulling, not the harness. Pairing a good harness with loose leash walking training helps your dog understand what you're asking, so you can both enjoy your walks. Your dog (and your arm) will thank you.
What if my dog already wears a prong collar?
First, no guilt! You were doing what you'd been told would help. Switching to a harness is simple, but expect some pulling to come back at first. That's not the harness failing; it's your dog showing you where the training gaps are. A few weeks of loose leash practice will get you there
Want help getting started? Tell me about your dog and we'll find the right plan together.
Comments